1
General Buick Tech / MAF Upgrade or SD?
« on: February 21 2019, 11:42:07 PM »
I was looking to upgrade my stock MAF with a 3.5" LS MAF and increase my intake piping diameter (~$300 for the translator and MAF + piping cost). So I started researching and I see a lot of threads on removing the MAF and going SD. So now I start researching SD for a few hours and I see there is a turbotweak SD2 chip but you need a powerlogger and 3 bar MAP which I don't have (I only have Direct Scan presently) so I would be into $850 for that setup.
Then I start looking at the aftermarket ECU / engine management systems which look interesting and I cam across the XFI Sportsman which replaces the ECU and is $999. From my research it seemed most people using the XFI Sportsman have more serious cars than I have, so it may not be good for what I have now but I could be wrong.
So now I am in a conundrum. Do I buy the MAF and translator or do I put the money towards the SD setup which is only a few hundred more. Which one is better for street driving? If the XFI sportsman can be used on other engines in the future that would be a plus (I'm sure I can find this with some research). Is the XFI sportsman much less of a system than the other more expensive SD options (MS3PRO, Eric's ECU GN, or the standard XFI model)? I really like the look of Eric's ECU GN but I can't justify getting something like that with my set-up. If the sportsman can interface with a universal gauge like this, or communicate with an android dash than that would help future proof it. I have read a lot of good things with the SD2 chip but there is less information on the sportsman, likely because it is fairly new. If the sportsman is simple enough to tweak once you get experience with it, then it would enable me to update it myself as I add parts in the future which would be a real plus.
Is anyone running the sportsman in a less aggressive street car? Does anyone have experience with both the SD2 chip and the sportsman and if so what are the pluses and minuses of both? Would SD be noticeably better in performance for a set-up like I have or is it just more fun to tinker with?
Details about my set-up:- 42 lb injectors- TE44 turbo- 2800 stall converter- Front mount intercooler - Adjustable fuel pressure regulator- Turbotweak chip
- Plan to add alcohol injection next.
Then I start looking at the aftermarket ECU / engine management systems which look interesting and I cam across the XFI Sportsman which replaces the ECU and is $999. From my research it seemed most people using the XFI Sportsman have more serious cars than I have, so it may not be good for what I have now but I could be wrong.
So now I am in a conundrum. Do I buy the MAF and translator or do I put the money towards the SD setup which is only a few hundred more. Which one is better for street driving? If the XFI sportsman can be used on other engines in the future that would be a plus (I'm sure I can find this with some research). Is the XFI sportsman much less of a system than the other more expensive SD options (MS3PRO, Eric's ECU GN, or the standard XFI model)? I really like the look of Eric's ECU GN but I can't justify getting something like that with my set-up. If the sportsman can interface with a universal gauge like this, or communicate with an android dash than that would help future proof it. I have read a lot of good things with the SD2 chip but there is less information on the sportsman, likely because it is fairly new. If the sportsman is simple enough to tweak once you get experience with it, then it would enable me to update it myself as I add parts in the future which would be a real plus.
Is anyone running the sportsman in a less aggressive street car? Does anyone have experience with both the SD2 chip and the sportsman and if so what are the pluses and minuses of both? Would SD be noticeably better in performance for a set-up like I have or is it just more fun to tinker with?
Details about my set-up:- 42 lb injectors- TE44 turbo- 2800 stall converter- Front mount intercooler - Adjustable fuel pressure regulator- Turbotweak chip
- Plan to add alcohol injection next.